Sheffield Lake Fishing Reports (December 2024)

Robert Hughey
Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio
Reported: 4 weeks ago

Perch is still going strong around the island area. Stickers and spreaders tipped with shinners are working. Walleyes are being caught from Cleveland west to islands. Trollingis the key right now. Stick baits and spoons are working. The catches are averaging 5 pounds. Walleyes are still moving west for the...

See Full Report & Photos >

Robert Hughey Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio Reported: 4 weeks ago

Perch is still going strong around the island area. Stickers and spreaders tipped with shinners are working. Walleyes are being caught from Cleveland west to islands. Trollingis the key right now. Stick baits and spoons are working. The catches are averaging 5 pounds. Walleyes are still moving west for the winter set. Night fishing is going on. Catching eyes based on the weather. It'll continue until ice

Scroll for more Close

Ronnie Rhodes
Sheffield Lake, Ohio
Reported: 1 month ago

Fishing is pretty good, lots of big big wind, not fun lol. Water temp needs to go down a bunch for the really big fish to start chopping.

See Full Report & Photos >

Ronnie Rhodes Sheffield Lake, Ohio Reported: 1 month ago

Fishing is pretty good, lots of big big wind, not fun lol. Water temp needs to go down a bunch for the really big fish to start chopping.

Scroll for more Close

Robert Hughey
Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio
Reported: 2 years ago

If you can get out due to the weather, the trollers are doing well off the south shore. Limits of trophy eyes are coming in to the docks. Both perch and walleye are being taken on shore. Activity will continue to be slow until ice season comes in.

See Full Report & Photos >

Robert Hughey Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio Reported: 2 years ago

If you can get out due to the weather, the trollers are doing well off the south shore. Limits of trophy eyes are coming in to the docks. Both perch and walleye are being taken on shore. Activity will continue to be slow until ice season comes in.

Scroll for more Close

Ronnie Rhodes
Sheffield Lake, Ohio
Reported: 2 years ago

Well this November been crazy hot, lots of fish but cold fishing for sure . Looks like Ohio walleye fishing is coming to a end pretty soon but get ready for next year.

See Full Report & Photos >

Ronnie Rhodes Sheffield Lake, Ohio Reported: 2 years ago

Well this November been crazy hot, lots of fish but cold fishing for sure . Looks like Ohio walleye fishing is coming to a end pretty soon but get ready for next year.

Scroll for more Close

Ryan Raines
Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio
Reported: 2 years ago

Hi David, I'm just getting back from about a month in the mountains of Colorado, so only a couple days on the water since my return. Right now the focus in pa waters of Lake Erie are primarily smallmouth and lake trout in shallow with some walleye mixed in. More...

See Full Report & Photos >

Ryan Raines Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio Reported: 2 years ago

Hi David,
I'm just getting back from about a month in the mountains of Colorado, so only a couple days on the water since my return.
Right now the focus in pa waters of Lake Erie are primarily smallmouth and lake trout in shallow with some walleye mixed in.
More to follow as I get more information, but there are some good fish around.

Scroll for more Close

Ronnie Rhodes
Sheffield Lake, Ohio
Reported: 2 years ago

Fishing been just great , walleye from 2lbs to 8lbs are starting to show up. We are trolling stick baits and weights to get to the proper depth. I’m running trips till the end of November but I only have a very few days left.

See Full Report & Photos >

Ronnie Rhodes Sheffield Lake, Ohio Reported: 2 years ago

Fishing been just great , walleye from 2lbs to 8lbs are starting to show up. We are trolling stick baits and weights to get to the proper depth. I’m running trips till the end of November but I only have a very few days left.

Scroll for more Close

Robert Hughey
Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio
Reported: 2 years ago

Great week for both walleye, perch, and weather. The shinners are really available at the bait shops and nice size perch limits are coming in right now. A good bite around the islands, try not to get into a pack of boats, just fish outside them by yourself. The walleye...

See Full Report & Photos >

Robert Hughey Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio Reported: 2 years ago

Great week for both walleye, perch, and weather. The shinners are really available at the bait shops and nice size perch limits are coming in right now. A good bite around the islands, try not to get into a pack of boats, just fish outside them by yourself. The walleye are heating up on the rocks and deep water. Working the walleye rigs in the rocks are producing. Trolling stick baits with diapers. Truetrips and lead in 35 to 45 foot of water are producing large walleye right now. The ten day forecast looks good for fishable weather .

Scroll for more Close

Robert Hughey
Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio
Reported: 2 years ago

Lake erie fishing report, 9/26. Due to high winds the boats won't see any fishing activity until Thursday. Water temperature is starting to drop and the perch are starting to hit in 12 to 25 foot. Smallmouth gong strong around the islands and Canadian waters. Soon craws will be gone...

See Full Report & Photos >

Robert Hughey Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio Reported: 2 years ago

Lake erie fishing report, 9/26. Due to high winds the boats won't see any fishing activity until Thursday. Water temperature is starting to drop and the perch are starting to hit in 12 to 25 foot. Smallmouth gong strong around the islands and Canadian waters. Soon craws will be gone and large minnows will work.
Walleye in the shallows are still producing. Trolleys are catching east of Kelley's Island to the sand bar. Anglers are starting to switch back to body baits.

Scroll for more Close