Gardiners Island Fishing Reports (December 2025)

Tom Mikoleski
Ridge, New York
Reported: 3 years ago

Summer fishing in full swing in Montauk. Stripers hanging in there, though not a savage bite any longer. Night trips still producing. Big fluke have definitely been on the rise. Lots of quality keepers from 3-6 pounds with enough doormat activity to keep it interesting. Sea bass and porgies both...

See Full Report & Photos >

Tom Mikoleski Ridge, New York Reported: 3 years ago

Summer fishing in full swing in Montauk. Stripers hanging in there, though not a savage bite any longer. Night trips still producing. Big fluke have definitely been on the rise. Lots of quality keepers from 3-6 pounds with enough doormat activity to keep it interesting. Sea bass and porgies both continue to be abundant. These great eating fish can be found and caught anywhere there's hard bottom.

Scroll for more Close

Alfred Cacciola
Montauk, New York
Reported: 3 years ago

Tunas are here. Bass fishing is great. Catching them on live baits and mostly artificials

See Full Report & Photos >

Alfred Cacciola Montauk, New York Reported: 3 years ago

Tunas are here. Bass fishing is great. Catching them on live baits and mostly artificials

Scroll for more Close