Gardiners Bay Fishing Reports (May 2026)

Derrick N.
Southampton, New York
Reported 5 months ago

Blackfish and seabass has been excellent, most trips customers caught their limit.

See Full Report & Photos >

Derrick N. Southampton, New York Reported 5 months ago

Blackfish and seabass has been excellent, most trips customers caught their limit.

Scroll for more Close

Derrick N.
Southampton, New York
Reported 1 year ago

Tony had a great half day morning with a bunch of Fluke up to 6lbs.

See Full Report & Photos >

Derrick N. Southampton, New York Reported 1 year ago

Tony had a great half day morning with a bunch of Fluke up to 6lbs.

Scroll for more Close

Peter S.
Hampton Bays, New York
Reported 2 years ago

Yesterday we had a good day. We trolled up to white marlin and a Mako shark. Fishing is good

See Full Report & Photos >

Peter S. Hampton Bays, New York Reported 2 years ago

Yesterday we had a good day. We trolled up to white marlin and a Mako shark. Fishing is good

Scroll for more Close

Tom M.
Ridge, New York
Reported 2 years ago

Fishing for big stripers has been outstanding. Plenty of other action with bluefish, porgies, and sea bass too.

See Full Report & Photos >

Tom M. Ridge, New York Reported 2 years ago

Fishing for big stripers has been outstanding. Plenty of other action with bluefish, porgies, and sea bass too.

Scroll for more Close

Peter S.
Hampton Bays, New York
Reported 2 years ago

The Tuna Fishing was slow the past two weeks... However the fishing for Mahi- Mahi more than made up for it... On our last trip we boated 18 Mahi's releasing several small rats. The Tuna fishing should pick up after these Hurricanes pass us buy. These storms churn up the...

See Full Report & Photos >

Peter S. Hampton Bays, New York Reported 2 years ago

The Tuna Fishing was slow the past two weeks...
However the fishing for Mahi- Mahi more than made up for it... On our last trip we boated 18 Mahi's releasing several small rats. The Tuna fishing should pick up after these Hurricanes pass us buy. These storms churn up the ocean, and the Tuna go off their normal feeding cycle. Once everything settles down the Tuna will go back on the Feed !

Scroll for more Close

Peter S.
Hampton Bays, New York
Reported 3 years ago

The Inshore and Offshore Water Temperature is Warming UP... Big time ! That's right... Everyone knows we had a Mild Winter this year. The Offshore and Inshore Water Temperature is Warming Up at a fast rate, and that is what We WANT !!!! All the Inshore and Offshore Species will...

See Full Report & Photos >

Peter S. Hampton Bays, New York Reported 3 years ago

The Inshore and Offshore Water Temperature is Warming UP... Big time !
That's right... Everyone knows we had a Mild Winter this year. The Offshore and Inshore Water Temperature is Warming Up at a fast rate, and that is what We WANT !!!!
All the Inshore and Offshore Species will be at least Two to Three Weeks Early this year compared to last year.
I am giving a Heads Up to Book Early... That's because things will be accelerated this year with the warm water moving in sooner than expected.
The Inshore fishing for Fluke, and Sea Bass should be hitting good in early May. The Offshore fishing for Tuna should also be firing on all cylinders by the end of May, or the beginning of June at the latest.
Last year we had some great Fluke and Sea Bass fishing including some incredible Tuna, Marlin, and the best Wahoo fishing ever.
Book Now before the choice dates are Gone.

Scroll for more Close

Kenny H.
Montauk, New York
Reported 3 years ago

We got it done quick this morning! Enjoy the ocean bounty guys!

See Full Report & Photos >

Kenny H. Montauk, New York Reported 3 years ago

We got it done quick this morning! Enjoy the ocean bounty guys!

Scroll for more Close

Kenny H.
Montauk, New York
Reported 3 years ago

It was a beautiful day on the water for the Ken Kane charter today! We had a boat limit of sea bass, along with some nice tog and jumbo scup! Enjoy the fresh Montauk seafood bounty!!

See Full Report & Photos >

Kenny H. Montauk, New York Reported 3 years ago

It was a beautiful day on the water for the Ken Kane charter today! We had a boat limit of sea bass, along with some nice tog and jumbo scup! Enjoy the fresh Montauk seafood bounty!!

Scroll for more Close