Key Colony Beach Fishing Reports (May 2026)

Key Colony Beach Weather Forecast

Fishing reports straight from our guides in Key Colony Beach

Aaron Black
Marathon, Florida
Reported: 1 day ago

Aaron Black Marathon, Florida Reported: 1 day ago

May Fishing Report – Marathon, Florida Keys

The summer fishing bite is building fast here in the Florida Keys, and we have been staying on the fish!

Recent offshore trips have delivered classic “Mahi Madness” action with aggressive mahi crashing weed lines and floating debris. Anglers enjoyed nonstop excitement, including multiple hookups and beautiful keeper mahi coming over the rails.

Back on the reef, the bite has stayed steady with quality Yellowtail Snapper and Mackerel making great table fare. Jim’s recent 4-hour reef trip produced fresh fish for dinner and even turned into an incredible homemade fish sandwich just hours after leaving the dock.

With warming water temperatures, calmer conditions, and summer patterns beginning to settle in, we’re excited for what’s ahead for mahi, tuna, snapper, and reef fishing in Marathon.

Whether you want fast-paced offshore action or a fun family reef trip, now is a great time to fish the Florida Keys with us!

Capt. Aaron

Scroll for more

Eric Rodriguez
Key Largo, Florida
Reported: 3 days ago

Great flats fishing with the weather stabilizing

Eric Rodriguez Key Largo, Florida Reported: 3 days ago

Great flats fishing with the weather stabilizing

Scroll for more

Robert Horachek
Big Pine Key, Florida
Reported: 4 days ago

Tarpon season is in peak season but I guess that I got distracted with permit

Robert Horachek Big Pine Key, Florida Reported: 4 days ago

Tarpon season is in peak season but I guess that I got distracted with permit

Scroll for more

Joseph Snyder
Islamorada, Florida
Reported: 4 days ago

We have been catching alot of mahi and tuna and the yellowtail snapper are still spawning and biting really good

Joseph Snyder Islamorada, Florida Reported: 4 days ago

We have been catching alot of mahi and tuna and the yellowtail snapper are still spawning and biting really good

Scroll for more

Ron Brack
Islamorada, Florida
Reported: 1 week ago

We've been waiting for the big girls to show up and they have . We're seeing the best trout fishing so far this year. We're also seeing some very nice snapper as well .

Ron Brack Islamorada, Florida Reported: 1 week ago

We've been waiting for the big girls to show up and they have . We're seeing the best trout fishing so far this year. We're also seeing some very nice snapper as well .

Scroll for more

Larry Wren
Islamorada, Florida
Reported: 2 weeks ago

The snapper bites been phenomenal on a medium days. We've been tuna fishing with a limit every time. Goliath was released, unharmed

Larry Wren Islamorada, Florida Reported: 2 weeks ago

The snapper bites been phenomenal on a medium days. We've been tuna fishing with a limit every time.

Goliath was released, unharmed

Scroll for more

BJ Meyer
Marathon, Florida
Reported: 2 weeks ago

Fishing is great. Lots of mahi showing up. Some sails around. Bottom fishing is getting better. Lots of big tarpon around as well Lots of permit on the wrecks also

BJ Meyer Marathon, Florida Reported: 2 weeks ago

Fishing is great. Lots of mahi showing up. Some sails around. Bottom fishing is getting better. Lots of big tarpon around as well
Lots of permit on the wrecks also

Scroll for more

Tom Kasprzak
Big Pine Key, Florida
Reported: 2 weeks ago

The yellow tail bite has been on fire lots of limits and bigger fish at the reef we have been catching grouper in the mix as well as mackerel inshore the mangrove snapper bite has been strong especially around the bridges and inshore wrecks

Tom Kasprzak Big Pine Key, Florida Reported: 2 weeks ago

Scroll for more

More Reports »

Target Species

View Full Species Seasonality Chart »

Show more species

Get it while it's HOT!
This species is in play.
You might get lucky (as long as things are in-season).
Couldn't tell ya! (no data)

Need a Place to Stay?

What's Biting in Key Colony Beach

« Previous

★★★★★
We loved our trip with Captain Johnny! He was super experienced and explained everything nicely. We all had a great time fishing for yellow tail and went home with enough fish for dinner! The weather was great, the music was great and the captain was great! We will be back!
Allison G. | May 8, 2026

Trip: Florida Fish Slam -23'
★★★★★
Great captain - great experience - 5 stars all around!
Christian F. | May 4, 2026

Trip: Epic Islamorada Inshore
★★★★★
Fantastic birthday trip fishing with captain nick. Great fishing with the family.
Nathan M. | April 30, 2026

Trip: Flats Fishing
★★★★★
Great day with Ken! Had a blast kept us in the fish all day long. Couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Will definitely be booking him again on our next trip.
Brian L. | April 29, 2026

Trip: Islamorada Fishing
★★★★★
We went out on a day when weather conditions were less than ideal and honestly I wasn’t sure we’d see much action at all. Despite the conditions, Captain Bill’s fishing and boat knowledge kept us in the game. The highlight of the trip was catching a 140lb lb Tarpon, the fight of a lifetime. If you are looking for a local guide who knows his craft, works hard, and has an easy to talk to personality, I would highly recommend Captain Bill.
Joe S. | April 28, 2026

Trip: Top Notch Tarpon Trips
★★★★★
Ben was very knowledgeable on the water and put us on the fish. We had a great day on the water and enjoyed every minute of the trip. We would strongly recommend Ben as a fishing guide.
Charles H. | April 27, 2026

Trip: Summerland Key Flats Fishing
★★★★★
Had a wonderful time. Chris our guide was the best! He knew what he was doing and really went out of his way to accommodate us. Will definitely be using the service again!
Jason M. | April 22, 2026

Trip: Islamorada Live Action Fishing
★★★★★
Great guide. Awesome boat. Aways enjoy fishing for tarpon.
George L. | April 21, 2026

Trip: Top Notch Tarpon Trips
★★★★★
Jim was great! He was a wealth of knowledge and put us on fish all day long. Was very patient with us beginners, and helped us pick it up quickly. Conversation was great throughout the trip, we talked all about fishing, travel, and the Keys. We would highly recommend to anyone looking for a great day of fishing while in the area!
Kerry C. | April 17, 2026

Trip: FL Keys Inshore/Backcountry Fishing
★★★★★
Captain Pete was fun and professional. A third generation backwater captain knows the secret spots and how to catch fish even in imperfect windy conditions. Capt Pete was putting us on the fish. We hooked up on tarpon, specs and a big ole 7 ft nurse shark too. Fully recommend! Urban Cowgill April 2026
Jeffrey C. | April 15, 2026

Trip: Flats Backcountry Quest

Top Fishing Trips in Key Colony Beach

Deep Sea Fishing in Marathon

Ultimate Angler's Paradise

100% (38) Guided by Brad

40 ft 1 - 12 People From $2,200

Inshore, Deep Sea, Nearshore in Tavernier

Fishing Tavernier

100% (30) Guided by Ben

20 ft 1 - 8 People From $700

Hot Trip

people are viewing this trip.

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing in Marathon

Marathon Premier Bottom Fishing

100% (38) Guided by Brad

40 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,100

Inshore, Flats Fishing in Homestead

Flats Fishing - 17' Maverick

100% (2) Guided by Alex

19 ft 1 - 2 People From $700

Deep Sea Fishing in Key Colony Beach

Offshore Fishing Trip

NEW Guided by BJ

32 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,500

Damn Good

Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.