Reel Deal Fishing Charters LLC with Captain Experiences

About Your Guide

A Certified Damn Good Guide is someone who goes above and beyond to show you an incredible experience on your trip. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.

Andrew Neystel

Certified Damn Good Guide

Independent Guide 15 years of exp.

Talkative

Instructional

Quality

Comfortable

Laid-back

Beginner Oriented

About Your Guide

Andrew Neystel

Certified Damn Good Guide

Independent Guide 15 years of exp.

HELLO! My name is Captain Andrew. I have over a decade of experience taking guests on deep-sea fishing charters in the Gulf of Mexico. This section tells about my life and background so you can know a bit about your captain before the trip!

I first began to hone in my skills on the “party-boats” out of Port Aransas Texas. Over the years I have worked aboard every vessel from Fisherman’s Wharf, Dolphin Docks and Deep Sea Headquarters. I spent the longest time working under and learning everything from the legendary Captain Marvin Horner Jr. aboard The Kingfisher.

After years of dedication to consistent hard work while following my passion for fishing…an opportunity of a lifetime to take things to the next level came into my life. I starred in a new Discovery Channel reality TV show called Ice Cold Catch. (It’s on Discovery+, Amazon Prime, Hulu, Peacock, SlingTV, Fubo etc…) I found myself traveling to Iceland to work aboard the Valdimar, a battle-scarred, tested, and true long-line vessel.

The workload intensity matched the larger-than-life personalities of the hard-working captains and crew mates. I experienced the world’s most treacherous waters while fishing through Arctic cyclones off the west coast of Iceland. I also worked through storm season all around Iceland, the North Atlantic Ocean, Denmark Strait as well as north of the Arctic Circle towards Greenland. Although tough, it was an amazing experience and I would do it again in a heartbeat.

My dream was always to have my own fishing charter business. I want to share a bit of why I love fishing and being so close to nature with the rest of the world. Ocean conservation and responsible fishing are very important so that future generations of fishermen and fisherwomen can also enjoy the same beauty one day! Upon returning to the United States, I realized that the time is now to take a step further once more and that I’m ready to show everyone the Reel Deal about fishing!!!

Scroll for more

Rapid Fire Guide Q & A

What’s the biggest fish you’ve caught?

Tiger Shark....bigger than google says they get

If you were cooking for all your friends what would you cook?

Sashimi fresh, seared tuna, mahi tacos

What’s your favorite band?

The Movement

What’s your favorite movie?

Knight & Day, Lord of War, The Perfect Storm

Rapid Fire Guide Q & A

What’s the biggest fish you’ve caught?

Tiger Shark....bigger than google says they get

If you were cooking for all your friends what would you cook?

Sashimi fresh, seared tuna, mahi tacos

What’s your favorite band?

The Movement

What’s your favorite movie?

Knight & Day, Lord of War, The Perfect Storm

What’s your favorite sports team?

Dallas Cowboys

What’s your drink of choice?

Anything with enough electrolytes to keep the grind going…or Imperial In Costa Ric

What was your last halloween costume?

Myself everytime

What do you want for Christmas this year?

To reach all My dreams one day, setting records and saving the ocean

How did you get started guiding?

I was sitting at the beach and saw a sportfishing boat heading offshore with shining golden reels, chicks in bikinis blaring music...told myself, " I want to do that!" Drove to Port Aransas the next morning before sunrise and walked up to the biggest boat I could find. The captain happened to be standing there. I said, "My name is Andrew Neystel and I don't know a damn thing about saltwater fishing. I want to learn everything and work on your boat." He said, "Be here tomorrow at 5 a.m." I showed up...and the rest is history.

What makes you different from other guides?

I have been providing charter clients with an enjoyable, good vibe and informative fishing experience for over 12 years now. I am patient, understanding and take the time to explain what to do the correct way in an easy to understand fashion. I don't just get you hooked up on the fish of a life time, I provide an education and funny experience while doing it!

Scroll for more

Reel Deal Fishing Charters LLC Trips

Choose a trip to get started

Damn Good

Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing in Port Aransas

State Water Reef / Shrimp Boat / Rigs

67% (3) Guided by Andrew

31 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,500

Damn Good

Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing in Port Aransas

6 Hour Offshore Reef & Wreck Fishing

67% (3) Guided by Andrew

31 ft 1 - 6 People From $2,000

Damn Good

Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.

Inshore, Deep Sea, Nearshore in Port Aransas

8 Hour Offshore Reef & Wreck Fishing

67% (3) Guided by Andrew

31 ft 1 - 6 People From $2,500

Don't see what you're looking for?

Recent Reviews of Reel Deal Fishing Charters LLC

4.3

based on 3 reviews

Amanda

Verified Review

We had a great time with Captain Andrew and team catching fish and navigating the waves. We were put right on the best areas to catch the snapper we were after. Also, when we forgot a jacket onboard in all the excitement of disembarking, Captain Andrew went out of his way to get it back to us. Thank you for helping make my husbands birthday one to remember!

Amanda

Verified Review

Scroll for more

Katelyn

Verified Review

This trip was so fun, we caught snapper, gafftop, and 2 stingrays, and one was a monster. Andrew knew where to go and his boat was very nice, he’s the best hype man too, always excited when a fish is on! Jeff was the bomb. He made sure we always had our lines ready and in the water and helped us pull up them Rays when our arms were wore out!

Katelyn

Verified Review

Scroll for more

Response from Andrew:

That was an epic time and y’all caught some epic fish!!!

Response from Andrew:

That was an epic time and y’all caught some epic fish!!!

Scroll for more

Adam

Verified Review

The booking was easy and seamless. Captain was on time and professional. However he did not put us on any fish and it turned out to be a very expensive boat ride.

Adam

Verified Review

The booking was easy and seamless. Captain was on time and professional. However he did not put us on any fish and it turned out to be a very expensive boat ride.

Scroll for more

Response from Andrew:

We tried fishing two different reefs areas about 8 different rigs. The same places that I fished and produced the day before. We got thrown with tough conditions all the way around, from choppy waves to a big party boat anchoring down in the middle of our best spot where we were catching fish. I tried my best, this is the first bad review I have ever received.

Response from Andrew:

Scroll for more

Response from Captain Experiences:

Hey Adam, thank you for this feedback. I'm very sorry to hear that the conditions were rough on the day of your trip. I know that Captain Andrew worked hard to get you all on some fish, and it's always disappointing to come back to the dock with an empty cooler. I do hope you will consider giving it another shot with Captain Andrew or any of the 1,600+ guides on our site. Please give...