Hey Trey, still doing more diving than fishing as folks have been taking advantage for some really good conditions for our traditionally slow period here down in the keys. We have had at least one coat front as it cools down over the next month we expect our fall/winter fishing to be off the charts!
Hey Trey, still doing more diving than fishing as folks have been taking advantage for some really good conditions for our traditionally slow period here down in the keys. We have had at least one coat front as it cools down over the next month we expect our fall/winter fishing to be off the charts!
Right now with the late summer bite, heading into October there is plenty of action Fishing for offshore, trolling live bait and jigging for mahis and tuna with the occasional summertime wahoo. With the reef Fishing, we are still getting mutton, snappers, yellow tails, red, groupers, and black grouper.
Right now with the late summer bite, heading into October there is plenty of action Fishing for offshore, trolling live bait and jigging for mahis and tuna with the occasional summertime wahoo. With the reef Fishing, we are still getting mutton, snappers, yellow tails, red, groupers, and black grouper.
Key West Fishing Report – Capt. Ryan Carter
Date: September 13, 2026
Greetings from paradise!
The fishing around Key West has been keeping us busy, and the transition toward fall is starting to show on the water. The heat is still here, but the fish are chewing, and there are plenty of opportunities to bend a rod whether you’re looking for dinner or a hard-fighting trophy.
The mangrove snapper bite has been excellent, with plenty of quality fish holding around structure, mangroves, and backcountry spots. Live pilchards and cut bait have been producing consistently, making snapper a great option for...
Key West Fishing Report – Capt. Ryan Carter
Date: September 13, 2026
Greetings from paradise!
The fishing around Key West has been keeping us busy, and the transition toward fall is starting to show on the water. The heat is still here, but the fish are chewing, and there are plenty of opportunities to bend a rod whether you’re looking for dinner or a hard-fighting trophy.
The mangrove snapper bite has been excellent, with plenty of quality fish holding around structure, mangroves, and backcountry spots. Live pilchards and cut bait have been producing consistently, making snapper a great option for anglers looking to bring some fresh fish home for dinner.
Jack Crevalle have also been putting on a show. When these fish push bait around the flats and channels, things can get wild in a hurry. They’re aggressive, powerful, and absolutely love to test light tackle.
If you’re looking for a serious fight, shark fishing has been producing some great action. Lemon sharks and other hard-fighting sharks have been active around the flats and channels, giving anglers plenty of opportunities for a memorable battle. Recent reports have also seen some impressive lemon sharks and big grouper action around Key West.
The tarpon bite is beginning to transition as we move toward fall. The big spring and summer migration is winding down, but there are still tarpon being found, particularly during the early morning and late afternoon windows. This past season was an exceptional one for tarpon, and there are still some quality fish around for anglers willing to put in the time.
You might get lucky (as long as things are in-season).
Couldn't tell ya! (no data)
What's Biting in Key West
Top Fishing Trips in Key West
Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
We thoroughly enjoyed our trip with Reel Easy Charters! Captain Larson made our son’s wishes come true of catching a barracuda and a shark. He was very attentive and patient as we learned how to fish with the different reels. Thank you for making our trip one we will always remember!!
Awesome trip I highly recommend them first time ever lobstering and spear fishing we had a blast and we did very well with the crews help def going again
Sean was a guide who puts anglers safety at the forefront of everything which all anglers should appreciate. Unfortunately one of our two days was blown out due to weather. He persevered trying to put us on fish until the weather became too unstable. He has 30+ years of guiding experience in the area. Enjoyed our time with Sean.
We had an absolute blast on this charter! Captain Paulie is a great captain. He put a lot of effort into making sure we were catching fish and enjoying ourselves. I highly recommend him and would go again.
Fished with Capt Zac B for the second year in a row, he puts us on fish every year. Fished with my wife and daughter this year and had a blast pulling on sharks, grouper, snapper, etc. my daughter caught 7 different species.
We had an amazing lobstering trip with Captain Paulie! He made the whole experience really fun and was also very informative throughout the trip. We checked a couple different spots and ended up getting plenty of lobster, which made it even better. He even cleaned everything for us afterward. Such a great experience from start to finish, and we would definitely recommend him!
Sign up to win $500 towards ANY trip. Winners drawn monthly.
Welcome to the Crew!
If you're lucky enough to win $500 we'll email you by the end of the month. If not there's good news: we still have thousands of Damn Good Guides who would love to take you out!