Damn Good Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Montauk

Check real-time availability and compare rates on Montauk mahi mahi fishing trips. Confidently book your next day on the water.

Choose a Date

Damn Good Guides

Experts Available 24/7

100% Weather Guarantee

Recently Booked Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Montauk, Ny

Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Offshore Tuna

NEW
33 ft 1 - 5 People From $2,800
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Overnight Canyon Trip

NEW
33 ft 1 - 5 People From $5,000
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Extended Offshore Tuna

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People From $3,400
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Extended Overnight Trip

NEW
41 ft 1 - 6 People From $5,000
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter near Montauk

Offshore Tuna / Marlin / Mahi Mahi

NEW
40 ft 1 - 6 People From $2,900
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing Charter near Montauk

Overnight Canyon Tuna

NEW
34 ft 1 - 3 People From $3,000

Top Types of Mahi Mahi Trips in Montauk

“Our Damn Good Guides go above and beyond, and we’ve handpicked every single one. We’re passionate about the outdoors and look forward to getting you out on the trip of a lifetime, every time.”

Jonathan and Attison   |   Co-founders   |   Austin, Texas

Target Species in Montauk

View Full Species Seasonality Chart »
  • Get it while it's HOT!
  • This species is in play.
  • You might get lucky (as long as things are in-season).
  • Couldn't tell ya! (no data)

More Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Montauk, Ny

Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing Charter near Montauk

Overnight Canyon Tuna

NEW
34 ft 1 - 3 People From $3,000
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter near Montauk

Offshore Tuna / Marlin / Mahi Mahi

NEW
40 ft 1 - 6 People From $2,900
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Extended Overnight Trip

NEW
41 ft 1 - 6 People From $5,000
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Extended Offshore Tuna

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People From $3,400
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Overnight Canyon Trip

NEW
33 ft 1 - 5 People From $5,000
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Offshore Tuna

NEW
33 ft 1 - 5 People From $2,800
See All Mahi Mahi Trips in Montauk

Other Trips in Montauk

Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

1/2 Day Bottom Fishing AM / PM

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People From $950
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Half Day Montauk Charter

NEW
41 ft 1 - 20 People From $800
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Full Day Montauk Charter

NEW
41 ft 1 - 20 People From $1,400
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Shark Special

NEW
41 ft 1 - 20 People From $1,700
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Tuna Special

NEW
41 ft 1 - 20 People From $2,500
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Shark Fishing Montauk

100% (1)
42 ft 1 - 6 People From $2,000
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Inshore Waters

100% (1)
41 ft 1 - 6 People From $950
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Block Island Black Seabass Trip

100% (1)
41 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,600
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Bluefin Special

100% (1)
41 ft 1 - 6 People From $3,000
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Deep Sea, Flats Fishing Charter near Montauk

3 HR Special

NEW
26 ft 1 - 4 People From $550
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Evening/ Night Striped Bass

NEW
25 ft 1 - 4 People From $650
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Half Day Trip: Inshore

NEW
35 ft 1 - 12 People From $800

Need a Place to Stay?

Everything to Know About Booking a Montauk mahi mahi fishing charter

What are the best mahi mahi fishing charters in Montauk?

Why should I book a mahi mahi fishing charter in Montauk with Captain Experiences?

Our Damn Good Guides currently offer 5 mahi mahi trips in Montauk, and the most popular trips in the area are Offshore Tuna guided by James, Overnight Canyon Trip guided by James, and Extended Offshore Tuna guided by James.

All guides on Captain Experiences are vetted by our team. You can access their reviews, click through trip photos, read bios to get to know them, and preview trip details like species, techniques, group sizes, boat specs and more.

Looking for kid friendly mahi mahi guides / fishing lessons in Montauk? Check out our beginner and family friendly mahi mahi guides in Montauk.

What types of mahi mahi fishing charters are common in Montauk?

Deep Sea fishing is the most popular type of fishing for mahi mahi in Montauk as well as nearshore fishing.

The most common fishing techniques in Montauk are trolling, heavy tackle fishing, and drift fishing but light tackle fishing and jigging are popular as well.

How much do Montauk mahi mahi fishing charters cost?

Prices for mahi mahi in Montauk can range anywhere from about $2,850 to $5,000, but the average price for a full day trip for mahi mahi in Montauk is $3,683.

Is booking a fishing guide worth the money?

Hiring a guide provides a number of benefits and many choose to book a fishing guide for a combination of experience, local knowledge, convenience, and cost-effectiveness.

Working with experienced fishing guides who know the best local spots and techniques can dramatically increase your odds of a great day. Having someone who is on the water every day and knows the area like the back of their hand is going to give you the best chances of success.

Booking a guide is also more cost effective, especially if you only get out a handful of times per year. When you consider all of the costs you would incur on your own such as the price of a boat, maintenance, insurance, gas, high-quality gear and tackle, repairs, and more, you’ll find that DIY is sometimes not worth the expense.

Even if you’ve got a great setup already in your home waters, booking a guide also provides a great opportunity to experience new techniques, new locations, or even a chance at a new target species to knock off the bucket list.

What month is best for mahi mahi fishing in Montauk?

The most popular season for mahi mahi fishing in Montauk is fall, and most anglers book their trips 13 days in advance.

Do I need a Montauk fishing license for mahi mahi and what are the bag limits for mahi mahi in Montauk?

See here for more information on fishing licenses in Montauk, bag limits for target species, and fishing season regulations in Montauk. When in doubt, your fishing guide will always know the right rules and regulations in Montauk.

What is mahi mahi fishing in Montauk all about?

In Montauk, Mahi Mahi, also known as dolphin fish or dorado, offer anglers an exciting offshore fishing experience. Known for their vibrant colors, acrobatic leaps, and delicious flesh, Mahi Mahi are highly prized by anglers for both their fighting abilities and culinary appeal. These pelagic fish can be found in the offshore waters off Montauk's coast, particularly around floating debris, weed lines, and temperature breaks where they hunt for baitfish and other prey species.

The peak season for targeting Mahi Mahi in Montauk typically occurs during the warmer months of the year, from late spring through early fall. During this time, Mahi Mahi migrate along the Atlantic coast, passing through the productive fishing grounds off the coast of Montauk. Anglers eagerly await the arrival of Mahi Mahi as they follow ocean currents and baitfish patterns, providing optimal conditions for successful fishing trips.

Anglers targeting Mahi Mahi in Montauk often utilize trolling techniques with brightly colored lures or rigged baits to attract strikes from these highly mobile and aggressive fish. Additionally, live bait fishing with rigged baits such as ballyhoo, squid, or mackerel can also be effective in enticing strikes from Mahi Mahi. By employing these techniques and understanding the behavior of Mahi Mahi, anglers can increase their chances of landing these prized game fish off the coast of Montauk.

What are the most popular months to fish for mahi mahi fishing in Montauk?

In Montauk, the seasons for targeting Mahi Mahi typically align with the warmer months of the year, spanning from late spring to early fall. During this period, Mahi Mahi migrate along the Atlantic coast, passing through the productive fishing grounds off the coast of Montauk. The warmer ocean temperatures and abundant baitfish attract Mahi Mahi to these waters, offering prime opportunities for anglers to target these colorful and highly prized game fish.

The peak season for Mahi Mahi fishing in Montauk usually occurs during the summer months, when water temperatures are at their highest and Mahi Mahi are most abundant in offshore waters. Anglers eagerly anticipate the arrival of Mahi Mahi as they follow ocean currents and baitfish patterns, providing optimal conditions for successful fishing trips. However, Mahi Mahi can still be targeted in Montauk's waters during other times of the year, albeit with varying degrees of success, as they may migrate to warmer or deeper waters during colder months.

Anglers and charter captains in Montauk closely monitor oceanographic conditions, such as water temperatures, currents, and baitfish activity, to determine the best times to target Mahi Mahi. By understanding the seasonal patterns and behavior of Mahi Mahi, anglers can plan their fishing trips strategically to maximize their chances of encountering these prized game fish off the coast of Montauk.

What techniques are popular for catching mahi mahi in Montauk?

When targeting Mahi Mahi in Montauk's offshore waters, anglers often employ a variety of effective fishing techniques to entice strikes from these colorful and highly mobile fish. One popular method is trolling, where anglers tow brightly colored lures or rigged baits behind the boat at varying speeds. Trolling allows anglers to cover a large area of water and mimic the movement of baitfish, increasing their chances of attracting Mahi Mahi. Anglers may also use teasers or dredges to further entice Mahi Mahi to strike.

Another effective technique for Mahi Mahi fishing in Montauk is live bait fishing. Anglers often deploy rigged baits such as ballyhoo, squid, or mackerel to entice strikes from Mahi Mahi. Live bait fishing allows anglers to present a natural and enticing offering to Mahi Mahi, increasing their chances of success. Anglers may also use outriggers to spread lines out and increase the fishing spread, maximizing their chances of encountering Mahi Mahi.

Additionally, anglers targeting Mahi Mahi in Montauk may utilize drifting techniques. This involves drifting with natural baits such as squid, mullet, or bonito, allowing the baits to drift naturally in the water column. Anglers may also deploy specialized rigs or spreader bars to increase the visibility and attractiveness of their baits to Mahi Mahi. By employing these techniques and understanding the behavior of Mahi Mahi, anglers can increase their chances of landing these prized game fish off the coast of Montauk.

What other species are popular in Montauk?

Aside from Mahi Mahi, Montauk offers anglers a diverse range of fishing opportunities targeting various species. One notable species to pursue is the bluefin tuna, known for its incredible speed, strength, and prized flesh. Bluefin tuna can be found in the offshore waters off Montauk's coast, particularly during their seasonal migrations along the Atlantic coast. Anglers targeting bluefin tuna often use specialized techniques such as trolling with large baits or lures, chunking with baitfish, or live bait fishing to entice strikes from these powerful predators.

Another sought-after species in Montauk's waters is the striped bass, prized for its strong fights and excellent table fare. Striped bass can be found in both offshore and inshore waters, particularly around structure, reefs, and along the coastline. Anglers targeting striped bass often use a variety of techniques, including trolling with artificial lures, live bait fishing, or bottom fishing with bait or lures. Striped bass fishing in Montauk is particularly popular during the spring and fall seasons when these fish migrate along the coast.

Furthermore, Montauk offers opportunities to target a variety of other offshore and inshore species, including bluefish, fluke (summer flounder), black sea bass, porgy, and shark, among others. In addition to offshore fishing, anglers can also enjoy inshore fishing opportunities for species such as bluefish, fluke (summer flounder), black sea bass, and porgy, among others. With its rich marine ecosystem and productive fishing grounds, Montauk provides anglers with a wide range of options for memorable fishing experiences, catering to anglers of all skill levels and preferences.

Other Fishing Species in Montauk

What's biting in Montauk?

View Mahi Mahi Fishing Reports from our damn good guides.

Didn't Find What You Were Looking For?

Our guides are Damn Good Guides, which means they’re vetted by our team of outdoor experts who know them on a first-name basis. We hand pick each and every one of them, and our network spans all across the US and beyond.

The proof is in the pudding, and we’re incredibly proud of our 4.9 / 5 average review score. Hit the button below to see more trip options:

See All Mahi Mahi Trips in Montauk