Damn Good Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Big Pine Key

Check real-time availability and compare rates on Big Pine Key mahi mahi fishing trips. Confidently book your next day on the water.

Choose a Date
4.97/5 Average Rating

Recently Booked Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Big Pine Key, Fl

Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing in Big Pine Key

Big Pine Offshore Fishing

100% (4)
25 ft 1 - 12 People From $1,200
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing in Big Pine Key

Florida Keys Destination Fishing

100% (4)
28 ft 1 - 8 People From $1,000
Veteran Operated
This trip is managed by a veteran of the US armed forces.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing in Big Pine Key

Chase Giants From Big Pine Key

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,150
Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Deep Sea, Nearshore in Big Pine Key

Reef, Wreck, Offshore Trip

100% (24)
26 ft 1 - 6 People From $800
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Deep Sea, Flats in Big Pine Key

Half Day (4hr)

100% (5)
27 ft 1 - 8 People From $800
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Deep Sea, Nearshore in Big Pine Key

3/4 Day (6hr)

100% (5)
27 ft 1 - 8 People From $1,000

Top Types of Mahi Mahi Trips in Big Pine Key

What makes Captain Experiences Damn Good?

Damn Good Guides

You will only find quality, vetted guides on Captain Experiences, and we know them all on a first-name basis.

Damn Good Guides

Experts Available 24/7

Our US-based team is available 24/7 to help you with any questions or concerns.

Experts Available 24/7

100% Weather Guarantee

We want to keep everyone safe, so if the weather is bad we'll work with you to reschedule at no cost.

100% Weather Guarantee

4.9 / 5 Average Rating

We hand pick our Damn Good Guides, and our network spans across North America and beyond.

4.9 / 5 Average Rating

“Our Damn Good Guides go above and beyond, and we've handpicked every single one. We're passionate about the outdoors and look forward to getting you out on the trip of a lifetime, every time.”

Jonathan and Attison   |   Co-founders   |   Austin, Texas

All Target Species in Big Pine Key

  • Get it while it's HOT!
  • This species is in play.
  • You might get lucky (as long as things are in-season).
  • Couldn't tell ya! (no data)

More Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Big Pine Key, Fl

Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing in Little Torch Key

4-6 Hour Spearfishing/Lobster

100% (24)
26 ft 1 - 6 People From $750
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing in Little Torch Key

3/4 Or Full Day Trip

100% (4)
33 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,200
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Nearshore, Snorkeling in Little Torch Key

Epic Fish And Snorkel Combo

100% (33)
30 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,150
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing in Little Torch Key

Reef Fishing Little Torch Key

100% (33)
30 ft 1 - 6 People From $750
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing in Summerland Key

Offshore

100% (4)
27 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,200
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing in Summerland Key

Summerland Key Offshore 34 Sea Vee

NEW
34 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,000

Didn't Find What You Were Looking For?

Our guides are Damn Good Guides, which means they’re vetted by our team of outdoor experts who know them on a first-name basis. We hand pick each and every one of them, and our network spans all across the US and beyond.

The proof is in the pudding, and we’re incredibly proud of our 4.9 / 5 average review score. Hit the button below to see more trip options:

Everything to Know About Booking a Big Pine Key mahi mahi fishing charter

What are the best mahi mahi fishing charters in Big Pine Key?

The best mahi mahi fishing charters in Big Pine Key are:

Why should I book a mahi mahi fishing charter in Big Pine Key with Captain Experiences?

Our Damn Good Guides currently offer 82 mahi mahi trips in Big Pine Key, and the most popular trips in the area are Big Pine Offshore Fishing guided by Tom, Florida Keys Destination Fishing guided by Alex, and Chase Giants From Big Pine Key guided by Felipe.

Our guides in Big Pine Key are rated a 4.97 out of 5 based on 8293 verified reviews on Captain Experiences.

All guides on Captain Experiences are vetted by our team. You can access their reviews, click through trip photos, read bios to get to know them, and preview trip details like species, techniques, group sizes, boat specs and more.

Looking for kid friendly mahi mahi guides / fishing lessons in Big Pine Key? Check out our beginner and family friendly mahi mahi guides in Big Pine Key.

What types of mahi mahi fishing charters are common in Big Pine Key?

Deep Sea fishing is the most popular type of fishing for mahi mahi in Big Pine Key as well as inshore fishing, nearshore fishing, and flats fishing.

The most common fishing techniques in Big Pine Key are drift fishing, trolling, and artificial lure fishing but bottom fishing and heavy tackle fishing are popular as well.

How much do Big Pine Key mahi mahi fishing charters cost?

Prices for mahi mahi in Big Pine Key can range anywhere from about $1,100 to $3,600, but the average price for a half day trip for mahi mahi in Big Pine Key is $1,512. The average price for a full day trip for mahi mahi in Big Pine Key is $3,022.

Is booking a fishing guide worth the money?

Hiring a guide provides a number of benefits and many choose to book a fishing guide for a combination of experience, local knowledge, convenience, and cost-effectiveness.

Working with experienced fishing guides who know the best local spots and techniques can dramatically increase your odds of a great day. Having someone who is on the water every day and knows the area like the back of their hand is going to give you the best chances of success.

Booking a guide is also more cost effective, especially if you only get out a handful of times per year. When you consider all of the costs you would incur on your own such as the price of a boat, maintenance, insurance, gas, high-quality gear and tackle, repairs, and more, you’ll find that DIY is sometimes not worth the expense.

Even if you’ve got a great setup already in your home waters, booking a guide also provides a great opportunity to experience new techniques, new locations, or even a chance at a new target species to knock off the bucket list.

What month is best for mahi mahi fishing in Big Pine Key?

The most popular season for mahi mahi fishing in Big Pine Key is summer, and most anglers book their trips 17 days in advance.

Do I need a Big Pine Key fishing license for mahi mahi and what are the bag limits for mahi mahi in Big Pine Key?

See here for more information on fishing licenses in Big Pine Key, bag limits for target species, and fishing season regulations in Big Pine Key. When in doubt, your guide will always know all the relevant rules and regulations in Big Pine Key.

Recent Reviews

  • ★★★★★
    Mike and Cole were awesome! Even though it was a slow fishing day for everyone, we still caught some keepers and had a great time!

    Maggie M. | July 1, 2026

    Trip: Key West Fishing More Than 6 Paxs

  • ★★★★★
    Brad & James were terrific! They were helpful, patient, & professional during the entire trip. They receive our highest recommendation!

    Rudy G. | June 25, 2026

    Trip: Key West Mixed Bag Trip

  • ★★★★★
    Had a great time. Was my first time snorkeling or spearfishing and Torre done great with us. Put us on fish right away

    Dalton B. | June 19, 2026

    Trip: 4-6 Hour Spearfishing/Lobster

  • ★★★★★
    Captain Joel (and first mate Sean) were great! They were warm and welcoming right off the bat! With their help, we caught tuna and mahi and had a great time. We were out in some rough waters and Captain Joel made us all feel at ease with his calm demeanor and skilled driving. Appreciated them preparing all our catch into fillets and steaks. Awesome time!

    Scott M. | June 7, 2026

    Trip: Marathon Offshore Slam- 50’ Bertram

  • ★★★★★
    We booked a fishing charter for my husband 60th birthday, and it turned out to be one of the highlights of our trip! Kevin and Max were absolutely awesome! Friendly knowledgeable, professional and committed to making sure everyone had a great time. They put us on the fish and we wound up catching a barracuda and a tuna, which made the day that much more exciting. The best part was bringing our fresh tuna to Kaya restaurant where they prepared it three different ways. It was an incredible experience from start to finish. If you are considering a fishing charter, we highly recommend Captain Experiences and especially Kevin and Max. Thank you for making my husband 60th birthday so special. Looking forward to doing this again!

    Ellie G. | June 2, 2026

    Trip: Key West Fishing More Than 6 Paxs

Narrow Down Your Search

Last updated: July 15, 2026

Enter to Win a

$500 DAMN GOOD GIFT CARD

Gift Card

Sign up to win $500 towards ANY trip. Winners drawn monthly.

By subscribing, you agree to receive marketing communications from Captain Experiences. To opt-out, click the unsubscribe button at the bottom of our emails. Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions

See All Mahi Mahi Trips in Big Pine Key