Damn Good Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Islamorada

Check real-time availability and compare rates on Islamorada mahi mahi fishing trips. Confidently book your next day on the water.

Choose a Date
4.86/5 Average Rating

Damn Good Guides

Experts Available 24/7

100% Weather Guarantee

Recently Booked Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Islamorada, Fl

Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Offshore Thrills

94% (16)
40 ft 1 - 12 People From $1,100
Veteran Operated
This trip is managed by a veteran of the US armed forces.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Ocean Thrills With Captain Don

100% (16)
28 ft 1 - 4 People From $700
Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Islamorada Fishing With Capt Pete

94% (16)
37 ft 1 - 6 People From $850
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Deep Sea Trophy Hunt

NEW
45 ft 1 - 6 People From $950
Veteran Operated
This trip is managed by a veteran of the US armed forces.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Best Islamorada Sportfishing

NEW
43 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,100
Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Ultimate Offshore Thrills

94% (16)
40 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,400

Top Types of Mahi Mahi Trips in Islamorada

“Our Damn Good Guides go above and beyond, and we’ve handpicked every single one. We’re passionate about the outdoors and look forward to getting you out on the trip of a lifetime, every time.”

Jonathan and Attison   |   Co-founders   |   Austin, Texas

Target Species in Islamorada

View Full Species Seasonality Chart »
  • Get it while it's HOT!
  • This species is in play.
  • You might get lucky (as long as things are in-season).
  • Couldn't tell ya! (no data)

More Mahi Mahi Fishing Charters In Islamorada, Fl

Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Blue Water Freedive Spearfishing

100% (5)
36 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,100
Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Inshore, Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Islamorada Trolling / Wreck Fishing

94% (16)
37 ft 1 - 6 People From $850
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Islamorada

3/4 Day Trip

100% (5)
44 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,400
Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Trolling And/or Wreck Fishing

94% (16)
37 ft 1 - 6 People From $850
Damn Good
Certified Damn Good Guides offer 10/10 trips. Guides earn this badge through quality reviews, quick and responsive communication, and low cancellation rates.
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Keys Offshore Fishing Adventure

100% (15)
26 ft 1 - 4 People From $1,275
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin
Fishing in Destin

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Islamorada

Full Day Mahi Mahi Trip

NEW
23 ft 1 - 3 People From $1,000
See All Mahi Mahi Trips in Islamorada

Need a Place to Stay?

Everything to Know About Booking an Islamorada mahi mahi fishing charter

What are the best mahi mahi fishing charters in Islamorada?

Why should I book a mahi mahi fishing charter in Islamorada with Captain Experiences?

Our Damn Good Guides currently offer 52 mahi mahi trips in Islamorada, and the most popular trips in the area are Offshore Thrills guided by Paul, Islamorada Fishing with Capt Pete guided by Pete, and Ocean Thrills with Captain Don guided by Don.

Our guides in Islamorada are rated a 4.86 out of 5 based on 3806 verified reviews on Captain Experiences.

All guides on Captain Experiences are vetted by our team. You can access their reviews, click through trip photos, read bios to get to know them, and preview trip details like species, techniques, group sizes, boat specs and more.

Looking for kid friendly mahi mahi guides / fishing lessons in Islamorada? Check out our beginner and family friendly mahi mahi guides in Islamorada.

What types of mahi mahi fishing charters are common in Islamorada?

Deep Sea fishing is the most popular type of fishing for mahi mahi in Islamorada as well as nearshore fishing and inshore fishing.

The most common fishing techniques in Islamorada are trolling, bottom fishing, and live bait fishing but heavy tackle fishing and artificial lure fishing are popular as well.

How much do Islamorada mahi mahi fishing charters cost?

Prices for mahi mahi in Islamorada can range anywhere from about $900 to $2,400, but the average price for a half day trip for mahi mahi in Islamorada is $1,045. The average price for a full day trip for mahi mahi in Islamorada is $1,703.

Is booking a fishing guide worth the money?

Hiring a guide provides a number of benefits and many choose to book a fishing guide for a combination of experience, local knowledge, convenience, and cost-effectiveness.

Working with experienced fishing guides who know the best local spots and techniques can dramatically increase your odds of a great day. Having someone who is on the water every day and knows the area like the back of their hand is going to give you the best chances of success.

Booking a guide is also more cost effective, especially if you only get out a handful of times per year. When you consider all of the costs you would incur on your own such as the price of a boat, maintenance, insurance, gas, high-quality gear and tackle, repairs, and more, you’ll find that DIY is sometimes not worth the expense.

Even if you’ve got a great setup already in your home waters, booking a guide also provides a great opportunity to experience new techniques, new locations, or even a chance at a new target species to knock off the bucket list.

What month is best for mahi mahi fishing in Islamorada?

The most popular season for mahi mahi fishing in Islamorada is spring, and most anglers book their trips 35 days in advance.

Do I need a Islamorada fishing license for mahi mahi and what are the bag limits for mahi mahi in Islamorada?

See here for more information on fishing licenses in Islamorada, bag limits for target species, and fishing season regulations in Islamorada. When in doubt, your fishing guide will always know the right rules and regulations in Islamorada.

What is mahi mahi fishing in Isla Morada all about?

Located in the heart of the Florida Keys, Islamorada is renowned for its vibrant marine life and exceptional fishing opportunities. Among the many treasures of its azure waters is the prized Mahi Mahi, also known as dolphinfish or dorado. This species, characterized by its dazzling colors and impressive size, inhabits the warm waters surrounding Islamorada year-round, making it a favorite catch for anglers and a culinary delight for seafood enthusiasts.

Mahi Mahi fishing in Islamorada is an exhilarating experience cherished by both seasoned fishermen and novices alike. Whether you're casting lines offshore or trolling near the reefs, the thrill of hooking into one of these acrobatic fighters is unmatched. With its distinctive golden hue, vibrant green and blue accents, and elongated body, the Mahi Mahi is not only a prize catch but also a sight to behold against the backdrop of Islamorada's stunning seascape.

Beyond the excitement of the catch, Mahi Mahi holds a special place in the culinary scene of Islamorada. Its firm, mild-flavored flesh lends itself perfectly to a variety of cooking methods, from grilling and pan-searing to ceviche and sushi. Many local restaurants feature fresh Mahi Mahi on their menus, offering visitors the opportunity to savor the taste of the sea while soaking in the laid-back island atmosphere of Islamorada. Whether you're a fishing enthusiast, a food lover, or simply seeking a taste of paradise, Mahi Mahi in Islamorada promises an unforgettable experience for all.

What are the most popular months to fish for mahi mahi in Isla Morada?

In Islamorada, the Mahi Mahi fishing season is eagerly anticipated by anglers and fishing enthusiasts alike. This renowned sportfishing destination experiences peak Mahi Mahi activity during the spring and summer months, typically from April through September. As the waters warm and currents shift, Mahi Mahi migrate closer to the shores of Islamorada in search of food, creating prime conditions for anglers to reel in these prized catches.

During the early part of the season, anglers often target Mahi Mahi in deeper offshore waters, where they congregate around floating debris, weed lines, and underwater structures. As the season progresses and temperatures rise, Mahi Mahi can also be found closer to the reefs and along the edges of the Gulf Stream, providing ample opportunities for both offshore and nearshore fishing adventures. With its abundance of baitfish and ideal water temperatures, Islamorada offers prime conditions for Mahi Mahi fishing throughout the season.

While Mahi Mahi can be caught year-round in Islamorada, the peak season presents optimal conditions for landing trophy-sized fish and experiencing the thrill of the chase. Whether you're a seasoned angler seeking a challenge or a novice eager to reel in your first Mahi Mahi, Islamorada's diverse fishing grounds and knowledgeable charter captains ensure an unforgettable experience. From exhilarating offshore expeditions to relaxing days spent trolling near the reefs, the Mahi Mahi season in Islamorada offers something for every fishing enthusiast to enjoy.

What techniques are popular for catching mahi mahi in Isla Morada?

Mahi Mahi fishing in Islamorada offers a thrilling adventure with a variety of techniques tailored to suit different preferences and skill levels. One popular method is trolling, where anglers cruise the waters offshore, trailing lines with artificial lures or natural bait behind the boat. This technique allows for covering a large area and enticing Mahi Mahi that are attracted to the movement and colors of the lures. Trolling near weed lines, floating debris, or patches of sargassum often yields success as these are natural gathering spots for Mahi Mahi.

Another effective technique for targeting Mahi Mahi in Islamorada is live bait fishing. Anglers use live baitfish such as pilchards, ballyhoo, or small mullet rigged on circle hooks to attract Mahi Mahi. This method can be particularly productive when fishing around structure or areas with known Mahi Mahi activity. Casting or slow trolling with live bait allows for a more natural presentation, enticing Mahi Mahi to strike with their voracious appetite.

For those seeking a more hands-on approach, sight fishing is a thrilling technique commonly used in Islamorada's crystal-clear waters. Anglers scan the surface for Mahi Mahi, often identified by their vibrant colors or distinctive dorsal fins slicing through the water. Once spotted, anglers cast lures or live bait directly towards the fish, leading to exhilarating strikes and adrenaline-pumping battles. Whether trolling, live bait fishing, or sight fishing, mastering these techniques ensures an exciting Mahi Mahi fishing experience in the legendary waters of Islamorada.

What other species are popular in Isla Morada?

In addition to the prized Mahi Mahi, Islamorada offers anglers a diverse array of other species to target, making it a haven for fishing enthusiasts year-round. One of the most sought-after species is the mighty tarpon, known for its acrobatic leaps and powerful runs. Islamorada's flats, channels, and backcountry waters provide ideal habitat for tarpon, especially during their seasonal migrations. Anglers can test their skills by targeting these silver giants using a variety of techniques such as live bait fishing, fly fishing, or sight casting.

Another popular species to catch in Islamorada is the elusive bonefish, revered for its speed, stealth, and challenging nature. These sleek, silver fish inhabit the shallow flats and sandy bottoms of the Florida Bay and Atlantic Ocean side of the Keys. Bonefish are notorious for their keen sense of smell and sight, making them a prized catch for anglers who enjoy the thrill of stalking and presenting a perfect cast to these elusive creatures.

For those seeking a more adrenaline-fueled adventure, Islamorada offers opportunities to target apex predators like sharks and barracuda. Whether fishing from shore, flats, or offshore waters, anglers can encounter a variety of shark species, including bull sharks, hammerheads, and blacktips. Barracuda, with their lightning-fast strikes and ferocious demeanor, also provide an exciting challenge for anglers using lures or live bait. With its diverse marine ecosystem and abundant fishery, Islamorada promises an unforgettable fishing experience for anglers of all skill levels and interests.

Recent Reviews

  • ★★★★★
    Captain Dan and Ryan were fantastic. The ocean was pretty rough that day but they helped us have a great time and pull in quite a few fish. We’ll be back again next year and will definitely look to hire them again!

    Moira V. | November 8, 2024

    Trip: Deep Sea, Wreck and Reef

  • ★★★★★
    Great time with Capt. Daniel . Over 25 years of experience and it shows. Good guy that went the extra mile to make us feel welcomed.

    Brandon &. | September 13, 2024

    Trip: Deep Sea, Wreck and Reef

  • ★★★★★
    Great Experience!! Super knowledgeable Captain, learned alot from him and had a blast catching snapper.

    Jessica L. | September 7, 2024

    Trip: Ocean Thrills with Captain Don

  • ★★★★★
    Very good trip…Caught the limit on snapper and grouper. Fun guy to hang out with for the day! Highly recommend!

    Craig W. | July 31, 2024

    Trip: Ocean Thrills with Captain Don

  • ★★★★★
    We had a great time! They catered to all the fishing levels and interest! As one of my bridesmaid’s said… what a perfect activity we fished, we chilled on the boat, we talked, drank, napped, and sunned at our own liking.

    Madison T. | July 30, 2024

    Trip: Full Day Trip

  • ★★★★★
    Had a great time. Capt. Bill did and amazing job!

    Seth H. | July 11, 2024

    Trip: Full day

  • ★★★★★
    Fantastic trip with Capt. Joel and Darren. Got us on some great Mahi Mahi, and kept at it for the whole trip. Highly recommended.

    David L. | July 8, 2024

    Trip: Marathon Offshore - 30’ Grady White

  • ★★★★★
    On behalf of Warren Herndon, Wayne Hall and myself (Dexter Hudson), I would like to report that we had an outstanding time on our fishing excursion with Captain Don. Captain Don was very enjoyable to talk and visit with and he also patiently answered all of our questions, explaining what he was doing. And he worked like a Trojan baiting and putting new hooks and leaders on our poles after sharks robbed us of our catch when we reeled in too slowly. We did manage to reel in 22 good-sized Yellow Tail snapper and were able to return home as conquering heroes with meat for the table. Don not only cleaned the fish but provided several tasty recipes. The gentlemen did the cooking, the wives joined us in devouring the meal and we all had big smiles on our faces.. Thanks Captain Don! If or when we get back, you'll be the man we call!

    Dexter D. | June 25, 2024

    Trip: Ocean Thrills with Captain Don

  • ★★★★★
    Amazing, had a great time and was super helpful and nice

    Bart B. | June 17, 2024

    Trip: Offshore half day

  • ★★★★★
    Had a great time with Captain Don. He was very friendly, knowledgeable, and we caught a lot of fish.

    Shon M. | June 17, 2024

    Trip: Ocean Thrills with Captain Don

  • ★★★★★
    Captain Erik was on time and prepared. That 35 foot contender got us to the spot quick. Put us on his spot & pulled up some yellowtail and a half dozen keeper mutton. Two jumbos 10 and 15 pounds.

    Gil L. | June 9, 2024

    Trip: Reef Fishing Action

  • ★★★★★
    I highly recommend Anthony if you want to fish out of Key Largo. He was obviously respected by the other guides we met while we were fishing and demonstrated a great knowledge of the local water and the best places to find different species of fish. Additionally, he had excellent equipment that was in very good shape. This includes his boat. Even more important was his willingness to conduct the type of trip I wanted for my grandchildren's first fishing trip. He is also extremely affable and fun to be with. If I go back to the Keys, I won't look for a different guide. I will just call Anthony and ask, "What's biting?".

    Allen T. | June 6, 2024

    Trip: Key Largo Bays and Backcountry

  • ★★★★★
    Great guide, nice boat, he kept on top of all fishing activities to insure a good experience.

    Allan S. | June 6, 2024

    Trip: Offshore half day

  • ★★★★★
    Pete and Kristy were absolutely awesome! We had an excellent time with the Louisiana/Texas combo ;) Captain Pete was patient about explaining the estuary of the Keys and species. We caught 6 different species and 3 sharks! Great time- see ya’ll next year🦈🎣😃

    Andrew W. | June 5, 2024

    Trip: Islamorada Fishing with Capt Pete

  • ★★★★★
    Our team of 6 went inshore fishing and got plenty of mangrove snappers! The captain Chris was very informative and friendly. He took us to different spots to catch fish and get a nice breezy ride with amazing scenery of Florida keys.

    Iryna B. | June 3, 2024

    Trip: Keys Offshore Fishing Adventure

  • ★★★★★
    We had an amazing time on a tough fishing day, would definitely book again when I am in the area. Andrew is great with the kids, and super patient with the beginners. He did everything he could to put us on fish. He also pointed out the abundance of wildlife, including sea turtles, hammerhead sharks, and a manatee. Everything we could hope for with my son's first saltwater fishing adventure.

    William S. | May 21, 2024

    Trip: Key Largo Offshore

  • ★★★★★
    We booked a 3/4 day after speaking with the captain the (plan) was made to shoot out deep and if we were not hitting them we would come in on the 3/4 day booking rather than a full day. Captain troy and his first mate worked as hard as I have ever seen to get fish on the boat. Not sure but at one time I think he had a deep running plug in one marlin plug and 4 top water trolling plugs so it looked like they were shooting for many different depths. We finally got into the mahi-mahi it was on. The first mate and captain maneuvered through 4 men as quick as humanly possible pulling fish off the lines and baiting hooks and handing them back. The only true way to explain it would be controlled chaos. These guys are GREAT at what they do and both the first mate and the captain seem to be fantastic people in there own right. So if your looking for a hard working boat stop here at Miller Time....

    Vance T. | May 21, 2024

    Trip: 3/4 Day Trip

  • ★★★★★
    Great fishing. Captain Paul delivered and put us on plenty of Mahi-Mahi. 5 star experience.

    Gary A. | May 19, 2024

    Trip: Offshore Thrills

  • ★★★★★
    We had a rough weather day but Capt Joe Joe put us on a lot of Mahi off shore and Yellowtail closer in. Outstanding day for our group and great boat handling skills from our captain and first mate. Will definitely book with them again.

    Arthur D. | May 5, 2024

    Trip: Marathon Offshore Slam- 50’ Bertram

  • ★★★★★
    Very good inshore trip - caught plenty of fish and numerous species. Planning to book again next year,

    David S. | April 26, 2024

    Trip: Marathon Offshore - 30’ Grady White

What's biting in Islamorada?

View Mahi Mahi Fishing Reports from our damn good guides.

Didn't Find What You Were Looking For?

Our guides are Damn Good Guides, which means they’re vetted by our team of outdoor experts who know them on a first-name basis. We hand pick each and every one of them, and our network spans all across the US and beyond.

The proof is in the pudding, and we’re incredibly proud of our 4.9 / 5 average review score. Hit the button below to see more trip options:

See All Mahi Mahi Trips in Islamorada