facebook pixel

Thresher Shark Fishing Charters In Montauk

Easily find a Montauk fishing guide that fits your needs. Confidently book your next day on the water.


Experts Available 24/7

Licensed & Insured Guides

100% Weather Guarantee

Recently Booked Thresher Shark Fishing Charters Near Montauk, Ny

Fishing in Montauk

Deep Sea, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Point Sportfishing

NEW
42 ft 1 - 6 People $$$
Fishing in Montauk

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Offshore Shark And Tuna

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People $$$
Fishing in Montauk

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Shark Special

NEW
41 ft 1 - 20 People $$$
Fishing in Montauk

Inshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Inshore Chase

NEW
46 ft 1 - 6 People $$
Fishing in Hampton Bays

Deep Sea, Flats, Inshore Fishing Charter in Hampton Bays

Inshore Insanity!

NEW
26 ft 1 - 4 People $$

“Our Damn Good Guides go above and beyond to provide you an incredible trip, and we’ve handpicked every single one. We’re passionate about the outdoors and about empowering people to find the perfect-match guide for the trip of a lifetime, every time.”

Jonathan and Attison   |   Co-founders   |   Austin, Texas

Other Trips in Montauk

Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Montauk Inshore Slam - 38’ Bertram in Montauk

Get out on the beautiful waters surrounding Montauk with Captain Al, a local legend and one of the most seasoned charter guides out there! You'll be hunting everything the inshore East Coast has to offer, including Striped Bass, Bluefish, Dorado, Porgy, Flounder, and more. Don't miss this opportunity to go after such a wide range of fighting fish, eating fish, and picture-worthy trophies! Captain Al knows where the best spots are, and how to put you right on top of your target. He has a variety of tools at his disposal, from light tackle for crazy fights to trolling gear to bring in fast-moving pelagic predators. On the day of the trip, you'll head out aboard Captain Al's 38' Bertram, which cruises at up to 34 knots, pushed by two 450hp Cummins 6TCA engines. She's a boat built for great fishing as well as a relaxing and comfortable day on the ocean. Captain Al will bring everything you need to reel in a prize, including rods, reels, tackle, and bait. To maximize your experience, bring polarized sunglasses, proper clothing, a hat, sunscreen, and most importantly, your Fishing License. Get ready to have a blast! Read More

Inshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Inshore Slam - 38’ Bertram

NEW
38 ft 1 - 6 People $$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Canyon Overnight Tuna Trip in Montauk

Get offshore and test your skill, strength, and stamina against monster Tuna on this overnight trip with Captain Al, one of the most experienced captains on the East Coast! This is a seasonal trip laser-focused on finding, fighting, and reeling in one of the Atlantic's , biggest fastest and most impressive fish, the Bluefin Tuna. Of course, there are other many pelagic predators out there as well, including Yellowfin Tuna, Sailfish, and Marlin. Any one of these fish could be a trophy catch, so come prepared for the right of your life! This trip is an overnighter, so you'll step off the dock after dark, then steam for several hours to the fishing grounds, which lie 75-100 miles offshore. You'll be fishing The Canyons, an area whose cold, rich waters attracts hungry Tuna and Billfish all summer. You'll be fishing from Captain Al's 38' Bertram, the ideal vessel for tackling big seas and big fish. It comfortably holds up to six anglers, and comes with everything you need for a perfect trip. Captain AL will also come prepared with all the necessary gear, including top-quality rods and reels, trolling lines and dredges, and most importantly, plenty of expertise for tackling these massive fish. To make the most of the day, make sure to bring the essentials: Polarized Sunglasses, Hat, Weather-Appropriate Clothing, Sunscreen, and a Camera! Read More

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Canyon Overnight Tuna Trip

NEW
38 ft 1 - 6 People $$$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Stripers, Sea Bass & More in Montauk

Get out there on the beautiful waters surrounding Montauk with Captain Chris, an expert guide and longtime professional fisherman who knows the area like the back of his hand. You'll be chasing every species that the inshore/nearshore East Coast has to offer, including Striped Bass, Bluefish, Porgy, Fluke, and more. Don't miss this opportunity to go after such a wide range of fighting fish, eating fish, and picture-worthy trophies! Captain Chris knows some of the best spots, and he'll put you right on top of your target. He has a variety of tools at his disposal, from light tackle for crazy fights to bottom fishing gear for hauling up heavyweights. On the day of the trip, you'll head out aboard Captain Chris' Baja sportfisher, pushed by a 300HP Cummins engine. She's a boat built for great fishing as well as a relaxing and comfortable day on the ocean. Captain Chris will bring everything you need to reel in a prize, including rods, reels, tackle, and bait. To maximize your experience, bring polarized sunglasses, proper clothing, a hat, sunscreen, and most importantly, your Fishing License. Get ready to have a blast! Read More

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Stripers, Sea Bass & More

NEW
1 - 6 People $$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Senior & Couples Trip in Montauk

Get out there on the beautiful waters surrounding Montauk with Captain Chris, an expert guide and longtime professional fisherman who knows the area like the back of his hand. This trip is meant to be totally relaxing and enjoyable, whether you're an experienced angler or not. You'll have the opportunity to go after a variety of East Coast inshore/nearshore species, including Striped Bass, Bluefish, Porgy, Fluke, and more. Don't miss this opportunity to go after such a wide range of fighting fish, eating fish, and picture-worthy trophies! Captain Chris knows some of the best spots, and he'll put you right on top of your target. He has a variety of tools at his disposal, from light tackle for crazy fights to bottom fishing gear for hauling up heavyweights. On the day of the trip, you'll head out aboard Captain Chris' Baja sportfisher, pushed by a 300HP Cummins engine. She's a boat built for great fishing as well as a fun and comfortable day on the ocean—perfect for couples and seniors. Captain Chris will bring everything you need to reel in a prize, including rods, reels, tackle, and bait. To maximize your experience, bring polarized sunglasses, proper clothing, a hat, sunscreen, and most importantly, your Fishing License. Get ready to have a blast! Read More

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Senior & Couples Trip

NEW
1 - 2 People $
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Trolling, Jigging, and Bottomfishing in Montauk

Known for being the home port for some of the best sport fishing on the east coast, choose between a 5-hour or 9-hour day trip exploring the prolific inshore and nearshore waters around Montauk NY with a first-rate Captain and Boat in Captain Jim! Captain Jim is here to accommodate your needs on these day trips! He offers a variety of half-day, full-day, and extended full-day trips of inshore and nearshore fishing. The half-day trips are broken into morning and afternoon charters. Morning trips usually depart at 6 am and return to the dock by 11 am. Afternoon trips usually depart at noon and return to the dock by 5 pm. You will be trolling, jigging, or bottom fishing for up to 5 hours targeting Striped Bass, Bluefish, Fluke, Black Sea Bass, Porgies, Black Fish, Cod, and Ling The full-day trips usually depart the dock at 6 am and return at 3 pm. On this trip you will be targeting multiple species by trolling, drifting, jigging, and anchoring depending on the type of fish you would like to catch. This trip is ideal for those wishing to spend a full day on the water for up to 9 hours and looking for more say in what they'd like to target. Generally, the target species are similar to the half-day trips, just chasing larger specimens and more of them! On the day of your trip, you’ll be Stepping aboard Captain Jim’s gorgeous 32’ Topaz Sportfish powered by twin Caterpillar engines pushing 640 HP. Topaz Express boats are notorious for their comfy rides. Being safe on the water is the main priority of Captain Jim. His boat is equipped with an Acr Class 1 Eperb, First Aid Bag, Throw Ring, Lifejackets, and even a Switlik Solas A Life Raft. Not only does he have top-of-the-line safety features but he has all the Mac Daddy electronics such as a colored fish finder, 64-mile radar, chart plotter, spotlights, and one hell of a stereo. The cockpit and cabin were built completely custom with insulated fish boxes, pompanette seats, LED lighting, a teal dinette, a bathroom, and even A/C! All you need to bring is a Montauk saltwater fishing license and your food, drinks, a hat, sunscreen, and polarized sunglasses. Jim will take care of the rest! Read More

Inshore, Nearshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Trolling, Jigging, And Bottomfishing

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People $$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Offshore Shark and Tuna in Montauk

On this trip, Captain Jim will be motoring you out up to 30 miles offshore and targeting larger species that swim down below. Typical shark species you will find on this adventure include Mako, Thresher, and Blue Sharks. Typically the tuna species will include Bluefin, Bonita, False Albacore, and Yellowfin. If you are lucky, you can encounter White Marlin and Mahi Mahi too! This trip is usually up to 10 hours. Step aboard Captain Jim’s gorgeous 32’ Topaz Sportfish powered by twin Caterpillar engines pushing 640 HP. Topaz Express boats are notorious for their comfy rides. Being safe on the water is the main priority of Captain Jim. His boat is equipped with an Acr Class 1 Eperb, First Aid Bag, Throw Ring, Lifejackets, and even a Switlik Solas A Life Raft. Not only does he have top-of-the-line safety features but he has all the Mac Daddy electronics such as a colored fish finder, 64-mile radar, chart plotter, spotlights, and one hell of a stereo. The cockpit and cabin were built completely custom with insulated fish boxes, pompanette seats, LED lighting, a teal dinette, a bathroom, and even A/C! All you need to bring is a Montauk saltwater fishing license and your food, drinks, a hat, sunscreen, and polarized sunglasses. Jim will take care of the rest! Read More

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Offshore Shark And Tuna

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People $$$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Extended Offshore Tuna in Montauk

If you're ready to get some serious fishing done, Captain Jim doesn't mess around on these 14 hr Tuna trips! You'll be ripping it out 40 to 70 miles offshore targeting Bluefin and Yellowfin tuna, and don't be surprised if you encounter White Marlin, Mahi Mahi, and other pelagic species pelagic species along the way. This trip consists of mostly trolling by dropping the outriggers and putting out a spread of 9 to 11 rods. You will be using top-of-the-line gear, artificial lures, and hand-rigged bait. The average time of this trip is up to 14 hours and departure times will vary. Step aboard Captain Jim’s gorgeous 32’ Topaz Sportfish powered by twin Caterpillar engines pushing 640 HP. Topaz Express boats are notorious for their comfy rides. Being safe on the water is the main priority of Captain Jim. His boat is equipped with an Acr Class 1 Eperb, First Aid Bag, Throw Ring, Lifejackets, and even a Switlik Solas A Life Raft. Not only does he have top-of-the-line safety features but he has all the Mac Daddy electronics such as a colored fish finder, 64-mile radar, chart plotter, spotlights, and one hell of a stereo. The cockpit and cabin were built completely custom with insulated fish boxes, pompanette seats, LED lighting, a teal dinette, a bathroom, and even A/C! All you need to bring for the epic adventures is a Montauk saltwater fishing license and your own food, drinks, a hat, sunscreen, and polarized sunglasses. Jim will take care of the rest to ensure your trip of a lifetime! Read More

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Extended Offshore Tuna

NEW
33 ft 1 - 6 People $$$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Overnight Canyon Trip in Montauk

If you are adventurous, this is the trip you have been waiting for! Montauk, located at the very tip of the South Fork peninsula of Long Island, is New York's largest commercial fishing harbor! It is known for being the home port for some of the best sport fishing on the east coast. Are you looking for some premier fishing, stunning views, and exciting adventures? You won’t regret fishing in Montauk with the immaculate service that Captain Jim provides. ​​Overnight canyon trips are the ultimate fishing experience. Traveling offshore to "The Canyons", located approximately 70 miles from Montauk Point, Captain Jim targets a variety of big game fish, including Blue Marlin, Bigeye Tuna, Wahoo, and more! On this trip, Captain Jim trolls during the daylight hours and then switches over to chunking with bait at night. Targeted species include Yellowfin Tuna, Bigeye Tuna, Albacore, Mahi, Swordfish, Wahoo, Blue Marlin, and more. This trip tends to typically fall around 28 to 30 hours. You'll step aboard Captain Jim’s gorgeous 32’ Topaz sportfisher, powered by twin Caterpillar engines pushing 640 HP. Topaz boats are notorious for their comfy rides. Being safe on the water is the main priority of Captain Jim. His boat is equipped with an ACR Class 1 Eperb, First Aid Bag, Throw Ring, Lifejackets, and even a Switlik Solas A Life Raft. Not only does he have top-of-the-line safety features, but he has all the electronics you could want, including a color fish-finder, 64-mile radar, chart plotter, spotlights, and one hell of a stereo. The cockpit and cabin were built completely custom with insulated fish boxes, pompanette seats, LED lighting, a teal dinette, a bathroom, and even A/C! Once you book your excursion, Captain Jim will meet you to get you started on your exciting trip. Full and half-day excursions are available and are inclusive of gas. All you need to bring is a Montauk saltwater fishing license and your own food, drinks, a hat, sunscreen, and polarized sunglasses. Jim will take care of the rest! Read More

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Overnight Canyon Trip

NEW
33 ft 1 - 5 People $$$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Montauk Classic Inshore Trip in Montauk

If you've been "feeling the bug" and wanting to go whack some big fish off the coast of Montauk, NY, then this trip has your name on it! Captain Adrian is a pro when it coms to finding, hooking, and fighting all the fish that the East Coast has to offer, including Stripers, Bluefish, Fluke, and Black Seabass. Not only are these fish a blast to catch, but they're good eating too! On this trip, you'll mix it up and do a combination of trolling, drifting, and bottomfishing. Covering the whole water column like this allows you to maximize your bites and hook up a wide range of species. Whether you're an experienced angler or a novice, there will be plenty for everyone on this trip! On the day of the trip, you'll head out aboard Captain Adrian's 32' Wellcraft center console. She's a great vessel for these waters, and is powered by twin Yamaha engines with a total of 500 horsepower. She's a boat built for great fishing as well as a relaxing and comfortable day on the ocean, with a T-top to keep you out of the sun. Captain Adrian will bring everything you need to reel in a prize, including rods, reels, tackle, and bait. To maximize your experience, bring polarized sunglasses, proper clothing, sunscreen, and a cooler with some snacks and drinks. Get ready to have a blast! Read More

Inshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Classic Inshore Trip

NEW
32 ft 1 - 4 People $$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Montauk Saltwater Fly Fishing in Montauk

Saltwater gamefish are the ultimate flyfishing challenge. If you're an experienced fly angler looking for a new challenge, or a conventional fisherman looking to try something new, this trip was made for you! With Captain Adrian, you'll spend your trip targeting Striped Bass and Bluefish—both classic East Coast saltwater species. Fly fishing requires some technique, so it wouldn't hurt to practice your cast a bit to even take a short course before you get out on the water. On the morning of the trip, you'll go aboard his 32' Wellcraft center console, a beautiful boat that's perfect for these waters. It's equipped with all the necessary gear and amenities to give you both a successful and comfortable charter experience. To maximize your time, make sure to bring proper clothing, a hat, polarized sunglasses, and sunscreen! Captain Adrian will provide everything else you need, including fly rods, reels, and tackle. Read More

Inshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Saltwater Fly Fishing

NEW
32 ft 1 - 4 People $$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Montauk Inshore Chase in Montauk

Get out on the beautiful waters surrounding Montauk with Captain Mike, a Northport, Long Island native and one of the best guides around. On this trip, you'll be chasing everything the inshore East Coast has to offer, including Striped Bass, Black Seabass, Bluefish, Porgy, Flounder, and more. This is also one of the few places where you can catch huge Thresher Sharks in inshore water! These fast, acrobatic sharks are incredible fighters, and Captain Mike specializes in hooking them. Don't miss this opportunity to go after such a wide range of fighting fish, eating fish, and picture-worthy trophies! Captain Mike knows all the hot spots, and how to put you right on top of your targets. You'll mix it up on this trip, using light-tackle techniques as well as bottomfishing and trolling. Each of these methods is useful for different fish species, so whether you're looking to fill your cooler, catch a personal best, or both, you're in the right place. On the morning of the trip, you'll go out aboard Captain Mike's 46' Bertram sportfisher, a beautiful boat that's perfect for these kinds of trips. She's powered by twin Detroit engines with a total of 680 horsepower, so you'll be on the fish in a hurry. She's also equipped with all the necessary gear and amenities to give you both a successful and comfortable charter experience. To maximize your time, make sure to bring proper clothing, a hat, polarized sunglasses, and sunscreen! Captain Al will bring everything you need to reel in a prize, including rods, reels, tackle, and bait. To maximize your experience, bring polarized sunglasses, proper clothing, a hat, sunscreen, and most importantly, your Fishing License. Get ready to have a blast! Read More

Inshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Inshore Chase

NEW
46 ft 1 - 6 People $$
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
Fishing in Montauk
trip description for Montauk Offshore Trip in Montauk

Get offshore and go after some classic big game species with Captain Mike, a Long Island native and a true pro when it comes to finding, hooking, and landing trophy fish! If you've never felt the tug as a Marlin or a big Tuna starts stripping line off your reel, then this offshore trip is for you. Captain Mike will do everything under the sun to get you where the fish are, but once that rod starts dipping, its all you! The fish you'll chase on this trip include the best that the Western Atlantic can offer, including Blue Sharks, Mako Sharks, Bluefin and Yellowfin Tuna, and more! These are all tough, hard-fighting species that will test your fishing abilities, so bring your A-game. On the morning of the trip, you'll go aboard Captain Mike's 46' Bertram sportfisher, a beautiful boat that's perfect for these kinds of trips. She's powered by twin Detroit engines with a total of 680 horsepower, so you'll be on the fish in a hurry. She's also equipped with all the necessary gear and amenities to give you both a successful and comfortable charter experience. To maximize your time, make sure to bring proper clothing, a hat, polarized sunglasses, and sunscreen! Captain Mike will provide everything else you need, including rods, reels, bait, and tackle. Read More

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Offshore Trip

NEW
46 ft 1 - 6 People $$$

Everything to Know About Booking a Montauk thresher shark fishing charter

What are the best thresher shark fishing charters in Montauk?

Our Damn Good Guides currently offer 5 thresher shark trips in Montauk, and the most popular trips in the area are Montauk Point Sportfishing guided by Pete, Offshore Shark and Tuna guided by Jimmy, and Montauk Inshore Chase guided by Mike.

All guides on Captain Experiences are licensed, insured, and vetted by our team. You can access their reviews, click through trip photos, read bios to get to know them, and preview trip details like species, techniques, group sizes, boat specs and more.

Looking for kid friendly thresher shark guides / fishing lessons in Montauk? Check out our beginner and family friendly thresher shark guides in Montauk.

What types of thresher shark fishing charters are common in Montauk?

Deep Sea fishing is the most popular for thresher shark in Montauk as well as inshore fishing, nearshore fishing, and flats fishing.

The most common fishing techniques in Montauk are trolling, live bait fishing, and light tackle fishing but heavy tackle fishing and bottom fishing are popular as well.

How much do Montauk thresher shark fishing charters cost?

for thresher shark in Montauk prices can range anywhere from about $883 to $2,870, but the average price for a half day trip for thresher shark in Montauk is $769. The average price for a full day trip for thresher shark in Montauk is $2,170.

What month is best for thresher shark fishing in Montauk?

The most popular season for thresher shark fishing in Montauk is fall, and most anglers book their trips 34 days in advance.

Do I need a Montauk fishing license for thresher shark and what are the bag limits for thresher shark in Montauk?

You’re in luck! Our fishing tours in Montauk don’t require you to purchase a fishing license – your group is covered by your boat’s captain. See here for more information on bag limits and fishing season regulations in Montauk.

What is thresher shark fishing in Montauk all about?

Thresher sharks are a captivating species found in the waters surrounding Montauk, offering anglers a thrilling and challenging fishing experience. Known for their distinctive long tails, thresher sharks are powerful predators that inhabit both nearshore and offshore waters. During certain times of the year, particularly in the summer and early fall months, thresher sharks can be found patrolling the waters off Montauk's coast in search of prey.

The thresher shark season in Montauk typically coincides with the warmer months when water temperatures are favorable for these pelagic predators. Anglers often target thresher sharks during the summer and early fall when they migrate closer to shore in pursuit of baitfish and other prey. This period presents prime opportunities for anglers to encounter thresher sharks while fishing offshore, making it a popular target species for those seeking thrilling offshore adventures.

Anglers in Montauk employ various techniques when targeting thresher sharks, including trolling with large baitfish or artificial lures, drifting with live or dead bait, and chumming to attract sharks to the boat. Thresher sharks are known for their acrobatic leaps and powerful runs, providing anglers with an adrenaline-filled fight once hooked. With their impressive size and strength, thresher sharks offer anglers a memorable and exhilarating fishing experience in the waters off Montauk's coast.

What are the most popular months to fish for thresher shark fishing in Montauk?

The thresher shark season in Montauk typically spans from late spring through early fall, coinciding with the warmer months when water temperatures are conducive to shark activity. Thresher sharks are migratory species, and during this period, they migrate closer to shore in search of prey, making them more accessible to anglers fishing offshore. The peak season for thresher sharks in Montauk tends to occur during the summer months, when water temperatures are at their highest and baitfish populations are abundant, drawing thresher sharks closer to the coastline.

Anglers in Montauk eagerly anticipate the thresher shark season, as it provides prime opportunities to target these powerful predators in offshore waters. During the peak season, thresher sharks can often be found patrolling the waters off Montauk's coast, particularly around areas with underwater structure, drop-offs, and baitfish schools. Anglers targeting thresher sharks typically venture offshore in search of productive fishing grounds, where they can deploy various techniques to attract and hook these elusive predators.

As the fall season approaches and water temperatures begin to cool, the thresher shark season in Montauk gradually winds down. Thresher sharks may start to migrate southward as temperatures drop, making them less prevalent in local waters. However, anglers may still encounter thresher sharks sporadically throughout the fall months, providing opportunities for late-season fishing adventures. Overall, the thresher shark season in Montauk offers anglers several months of exciting offshore fishing opportunities, with peak activity occurring during the summer months when these powerful predators are most active.

What techniques are popular for catching thresher shark in Montauk?

Anglers in Montauk employ a variety of effective techniques when targeting thresher sharks, known for their acrobatic leaps and powerful runs. One popular method is trolling with large baitfish or artificial lures, such as spreader bars or swimming plugs, behind boats. Anglers troll at varying speeds, covering large areas of water to locate thresher sharks actively feeding near the surface. Trolling allows anglers to cover a wide range of depths and areas, increasing the likelihood of encountering thresher sharks in offshore waters.

Drifting with live or dead bait is another productive technique used by anglers to target thresher sharks in Montauk's waters. Anglers deploy bait rigs rigged with fresh baitfish, such as mackerel or bunker, or chunks of cut bait to attract thresher sharks near the bottom. Drifting allows anglers to present baits naturally in the water column, enticing thresher sharks to feed. Anglers often employ chumming techniques to create scent trails and attract thresher sharks to their fishing location, increasing the chances of a successful hook-up.

Once a thresher shark is hooked, anglers must be prepared for an adrenaline-filled fight. Thresher sharks are known for their powerful runs and acrobatic leaps, putting anglers' tackle and skills to the test. Anglers must use heavy-duty fishing tackle, such as stout rods and reels spooled with strong braided line, to handle the strength of thresher sharks. Patience and persistence are key when fighting thresher sharks, as they can provide anglers with a challenging battle before being successfully landed and released. Overall, thresher shark fishing in Montauk requires skill, preparation, and a willingness to tackle these powerful predators in offshore waters.

What other species are popular in Montauk?

Montauk offers anglers a diverse range of species to target aside from thresher sharks, ensuring there's something for every angler to enjoy. One popular species is the striped bass, prized for its powerful fights and delicious flesh. Striped bass can be found in both nearshore and offshore waters around Montauk throughout the year, with peak seasons occurring during the spring and fall migrations. Anglers often use various techniques, including trolling with lures or live bait fishing, to target striped bass successfully.

Another sought-after species in Montauk's waters is the bluefish, known for its aggressive strikes and hard-fighting nature. Bluefish can be found in abundance in nearshore and offshore waters, particularly during the warmer months. Anglers target bluefish using techniques such as casting with lures, trolling with spoons or plugs, or bottom fishing with bait rigs. Bluefish provide exciting fishing opportunities for anglers of all skill levels, making them a popular target species in Montauk.

Montauk also offers opportunities to target species such as fluke (summer flounder), black sea bass, blackfish (tautog), and mahi-mahi, among others. These species can be found in both inshore and offshore waters, providing anglers with a diverse range of fishing experiences. Whether bottom fishing on wrecks and reefs for bottom-dwelling species or trolling for pelagic species in offshore waters, Montauk's rich marine ecosystem ensures there's always something new and exciting to catch.

What's biting in Montauk?

View Thresher Shark Fishing Reports from our damn good guides.

Didn't Find What You Were Looking For?

Our guides are Damn Good Guides, which means they’re licensed, insured and vetted by our team of outdoor experts who know them on a first-name basis. We hand pick our Damn Good Guides, and our network spans all across the country and beyond.

The proof is in the pudding, and we’re incredibly proud of our 4.9 / 5 average review score. Hit the button below to see more trip options:

See All Thresher Shark Trips in Montauk