Captain Al’s Fishing Charters in Montauk, New York

Guided by Alfred Cacciola

Deep Sea Inshore

About Your Guide

Captain Al is a highly experienced fisherman who has been working private fishing charters for over 35 years. He has been a passionate angler for many years, and has fished all over the US and the Caribbean, including the Florida Keys, Puerto Rico, Aruba, and many others. He also has extensive experience fishing in Montauk, and his in-depth knowledge of the area’s hot spots allows him to provide the very best charter experience for any group that comes aboard his boat. A trip with Captain Al is sure to be a great experience for any angler, whether you're a seasoned fish-fighter or a first-timer.

Captain Al’s Fishing Charters Trips

Get out on the beautiful waters surrounding Montauk with Captain Al, a local legend and one of the most seasoned charter guides out there! You'll be hunting everything the inshore East Coast has to offer, including Striped Bass, Bluefish, Dorado, Porgy, Flounder, and more. Don't miss this opportunity to go after such a wide range of fighting fish, eating fish, and picture-worthy trophies! Captain Al knows where the best spots are, and how to put you right on top of your target. He has a variety of tools at his disposal, from light tackle for crazy fights to trolling gear to bring in fast-moving pelagic predators. On the day of the trip, you'll head out aboard Captain Al's 38' Bertram, which cruises at up to 34 knots, pushed by two 450hp Cummins 6TCA engines. She's a boat built for great fishing as well as a relaxing and comfortable day on the ocean. Captain Al will bring everything you need to reel in a prize, including rods, reels, tackle, and bait. To maximize your experience, bring polarized sunglasses, proper clothing, a hat, sunscreen, and most importantly, your Fishing License. Get ready to have a blast! Read More

Inshore Fishing Charter in Montauk

Montauk Inshore Slam - 38’ Bertram

100% (7)
38 ft 1 - 6 People From $142 / person

Get offshore and test your skill, strength, and stamina against monster Tuna on this overnight trip with Captain Al, one of the most experienced captains on the East Coast! This is a seasonal trip laser-focused on finding, fighting, and reeling in one of the Atlantic's , biggest fastest and most impressive fish, the Bluefin Tuna. Of course, there are other many pelagic predators out there as well, including Yellowfin Tuna, Sailfish, and Marlin. Any one of these fish could be a trophy catch, so come prepared for the right of your life! This trip is an overnighter, so you'll step off the dock after dark, then steam for several hours to the fishing grounds, which lie 75-100 miles offshore. You'll be fishing The Canyons, an area whose cold, rich waters attracts hungry Tuna and Billfish all summer. You'll be fishing from Captain Al's 38' Bertram, the ideal vessel for tackling big seas and big fish. It comfortably holds up to six anglers, and comes with everything you need for a perfect trip. Captain AL will also come prepared with all the necessary gear, including top-quality rods and reels, trolling lines and dredges, and most importantly, plenty of expertise for tackling these massive fish. To make the most of the day, make sure to bring the essentials: Polarized Sunglasses, Hat, Weather-Appropriate Clothing, Sunscreen, and a Camera! Read More

Deep Sea Fishing Charter in Montauk

Canyon Overnight Tuna Trip

100% (7)
38 ft 1 - 6 People From $1,167 / person

Recent Reviews of Captain Al’s Fishing Charters

Russell L.


We loved the boat, Capt Al and Craig the mate. These guys put you on fish. !

Kelly M.


Absolutely great day filled with fun & memories that will last a lifetime. The Captain & crew were fantastic! Recommend highly 100%!

Dexter N.


Recommend Captain Al and his Mate Craig are constant professional. Captain Jack wants nothing more than your fishing experience to be great and will use all his experience to make it so.

Alex T.


Beautiful boat, and a great captain and mate. Put us on the fish and was clear where and how we were fishing to best make use of our time. Caught our limit and then some with some trophy fish mixed in.



We had a fabulous fishing day with Captain Al and his mate, Craig. They both did everything possible to make our fishing trip enjoyable, plentiful and amazing! Capt. Al is extremely knowledgeable, professional and provides a wonderful fishing experience. I look forward to booking another trip with him.

Michael P.


Took a trip out to Montauk with a few good friends and had an experience to let us Al a lifetime! We not only caught our limit on Stripers, four of us caught the biggest fish we’ve ever caught before. Captain Al had us on the fish all day and his deck hand, Steve, had the best personality ever! We caught around 35 fish, took in the beautiful views all around, and shared many laughs together! Exceeded our expectations!!

Peter B.


Afternoon best assassin’sl, we went right out record bass all day long we couldn’t have even done a full day our arms are so tired from just a half it was nice to see an old school crew and put us right on the fish and didn’t waste any time or money great great power and crew I’m not sure about the jack ass from Cujo Lol! He taught me something after fishing for 20 years out there I learned something from both of them today.


Black Marlin, Blackfin Tuna, Bluefish, Fluke, Mahi Mahi, Scup, Striped Bass, Swordfish, Yellowfin Tuna


Bottom Fishing, Cut Bait Fishing, Heavy Tackle Fishing, Light Tackle Fishing, Live Bait Fishing, Trolling

Types of Fishing

Deep Sea, Inshore

Start Location

474 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

Captain Al’s Fishing Charters Photo Gallery

Book a Trip with Alfred